Hidden Letter to the Editor: Scottsdale Apartments

This letter to the editor appeared in today’s Scottsdale Republic, but as-typical, not on AZCentral. I’m also going to flag it for the Quote of the Day!

I was fascinated to learn in a recent Scottsdale Republic article that, ac­cording to Phoenix City Council mem­ber Tom Simplot, “renting is the new buying.” We need to remind ourselves that the reason renting is more popular is a direct result of the housing market running amok.

A few years ago, when mortgages were given to people who should never have qualified, they were allowed to purchase overpriced homes that they couldn’t afford. Greed ruled the day and forced many unfortunate individ­uals into the rental market. When the American dream of owning a home has been replaced by the idea that renting is the new “American vision” for resi­dential living, I think we can all admit we have taken a giant step backward.

In the past few years we have — thanks to developers, bankers and oth­ers associated with the housing indus­try — encouraged folks to purchase properties they couldn’t afford, hyped the benefits of converting apartments to condos and now we are quick to jump on the apartment development band­wagon.

By overbuilding apartments, in spite of Simplot’s assertions to the contrary, we simply guarantee that when the housing market comes back and people are ready to buy again, we will have higher vacancy rates due to the glut of apartments, which will lead to lower rents and resulting issues [emphasis added]. Apartment development is booming, cash registers are ringing, developers are counting their blessings and people like Simplot are hoping that we are just a bunch of cash-strapped suckers.

Erica Stanton, Scottsdale

You may also like


  1. In many ways Scottsdale has done quite well in spite of themselves. Think what it would be like if they actually knew what they were doing.

    Fewer apartments, especially high rise.
    No silly talk about light rail.
    No heavy concentration of bars.

    1. Absolutely right, Jim.

      We seem to succeed in spite of stupid decisions–or worse, decisions made by our elected officials which are motivated by self-interest, self-preservation, and campaign contributions.

      Scottsdale has always been a leader and an innovator. Those days will be over if our inattentive electorate doesn’t wake up and get rid of cronyism in Scottsdale.

      As always, thanks for your comment!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *